Fenice Energy

Which Solar Water Heater is More Efficient: ETC or FPC?

Discover which solar water heater system, ETC or FPC, offers superior efficiency for your home, ensuring optimal energy savings and eco-friendly hot water solutions.

how to use solar water heater

Reduce your electricity bills by 90%

Did you know that Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) are way more efficient than Flat Plate Collectors (FPC)? They can transfer heat up to 163% better. This makes ETC very popular for both homes and businesses looking to save energy.

In the world of solar water heating, there are mainly two types: ETC and FPC. Both do a great job at capturing the sun’s energy to heat water. But, ETC beats FPC in efficiency. It’s important to know this difference when choosing a solar water heater for your home or business

Fenice Energy is a top provider of eco-friendly solutions in India. They really know their stuff when it comes to solar water heating systems. They can help you pick the best system for your needs. With their help, you can enjoy the perks of green technology to the fullest.

Key Takeaways

  • Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) can be up to 163% more efficient in heat transfer compared to Flat Plate Collectors (FPC).
  • ETC perform better in extreme weather conditions and can supply hot water throughout the year.
  • Flat Plate Collectors (FPC) are generally more affordable and have a longer system lifespan.
  • The choice between ETC and FPC depends on factors like climate, hot water needs, and budget.
  • Fenice Energy offers comprehensive clean energy solutions, including solar, backup systems, and EV charging, backed by over 20 years of experience.

Understanding Solar Water Heating Systems

Solar collectors are key in solar water heating. They take in solar energy to heat water. This way, they offer people an efficient and green hot water option for their places.

Solar Collectors: The Heart of Solar Water Heaters

There are two main types of solar collectors: Flat Plate Collectors (FPC) and Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC). Each type is unique in design and use. They fit various climate conditions and user needs differently.

Flat Plate Collectors (FPC)

Flat Plate Collectors (FPC) harness solar energy using the greenhouse effect. They have an absorber plate, usually copper or aluminum, with tubes to carry the hot fluid. These parts are in a box with a special cover to keep the heat in.

Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC)

Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) have a row of clear tubes, each with a heat pipe inside. They work in a vacuum to prevent heat from escaping. This approach lets ETC collect heat from outside, work well in cold or cloudy weather, and warm the water via a pipe.

Flat Plate Collectors: A Closer Look

Flat Plate Collectors (FPC) are well-known for their ability to change sunlight into heat effectively. They use the greenhouse effect to do this. This powers water systems using the sun’s energy.

Design and Working Principle

An FPC has an absorber plate, usually made from copper or aluminum. It has tubes or pipes to carry heated fluid. The plate is black to absorb more solar energy. And it sits in a box with insulation and glazing to keep in heat.

When sunlight hits the absorber, it warms the fluid in the tubes. This hot fluid then moves to a storage tank. There, it’s ready to be used for hot water in homes or businesses.

Benefits of Flat Plate Collectors

FPCs are a popular choice for many reasons:

  • They cost less than Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC).
  • They last a long time, typically 15 to 25 years, and need little maintenance.
  • They fit well on many roofs and buildings, making them versatile.
  • Although not the most efficient, they work well for saving energy for hot water.

Limitations of Flat Plate Collectors

However, FPCs do have some downsides:

  1. They’re less efficient than ETCs, transferring heat at 40% to 80% rates.
  2. They’re affected by weather, like temperature, wind, and clouds, which can lower their effectiveness.
  3. They need more space than ETCs to produce the same amount of energy, which might not fit every home’s roof area.

Choosing a solar water heating system should consider your home’s needs and the climate. Fenice Energy can help with its experience in solar, backups, and EV charging over 20 years.

flat plate collectors

Evacuated Tube Collectors: The Advanced Solution

Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) have a unique design. They are different from the Flat Plate Collectors (FPC). ETC have a row of see-through tubes with each tube having a heat pipe. The space between the tubes is emptied to make a vacuum. This vacuum cuts down on heat loss. It helps ETC work well in cold or cloudy weather. The heat is taken from the air and moved to the water through a pipe.

Construction and Operating Mechanism

ETC systems are made of many borosilicate glass tubes. Each tube has a heat pipe inside it. There’s a vacuum between the inner and outer glass. This almost stops heat from being lost. ETCs work great in all kinds of weather due to this vacuum insulation.

When the sun shines on the ETC, the outer glass gets hot. This heat is soaked up by the heat pipe inside. The hot water in the system gets heat from this pipe. An ETC keeps working well even when it’s cold or cloudy outside.

Advantages of Evacuated Tube Collectors

ETCs have many benefits over FPCs:

  • Higher Efficiency: ETCs can be up to 163% more efficient at moving heat than FPCs. They do this by keeping heat in better and moving it faster.
  • Year-Round Performance: ETCs work well even in cold and cloudy weather. This makes them a great option for solar water heating all the time.
  • Versatility: ETCs fit well in many homes and businesses. They offer choices in how they are set up and used.
  • Durability: ETCs are made tough, with strong glass and metal parts. This makes them last a long time with little need for repair.

Fenice Energy is a leader in clean energy. They have over 20 years of experience. Their team can help you pick the best solar water heater for your home or business. This choice will save you money and energy in the long run.

which solar water heater is more efficient etc or fpc

The debate over solar water heaters’ efficiency continues, focusing on Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) versus Flat Plate Collectors (FPC). Research highlights ETC’s potential to be 163% more efficient in heat transfer than FPC. This significant advantage positions ETC as a prime choice for those aiming for top-notch energy-efficient water heating.

Efficiency Comparison: ETC vs. FPC

ETC stands out due to the vacuum insulation within its tubes, which greatly reduces heat loss. This allows ETC to work well in all weather, pulling heat from the air and sending it to water via a header pipe. FPC, however, turn sunlight into warmth primarily through a greenhouse effect, which is more vulnerable to heat loss.

Performance in Different Climatic Conditions

Solar water heaters’ performance changes based on the weather. ETC shine in all conditions, staying efficient even in cold or cloudy weather. This makes them ideal for places with severe or changing climates. Meanwhile, FPC may perform better in areas with steady, strong sunlight year-round.

Cost and Maintenance Considerations

ETC may cost more to get started, but their long-term savings and reduced energy use often make up for it. They are also easier to maintain because of their sturdy build and lack of complex parts. This makes ETC a smart, less demanding choice for the future.

Before you choose a solar water heater, consider your household’s needs, the climate you live in, and your budget.
Fenice Energy provides expert advice and a range of clean energy options, including solar, backup systems, and EV charging. With over 20 years of experience, they can guide you to the best solar water heating solution.


Choosing the Right Solar Water Heater

When you pick a solar water heater, think about how much hot water your family uses. Look at the number of people in your home and what they use hot water for. This includes how much hot water you need and how warm you want it.

Assessing Your Hot Water Needs

The first step in choosing a solar water heater is figuring out your family’s hot water use. Look at how many people are in your home and how often they shower and do laundry. Knowing this helps you choose the right size solar water heater.

Climatic Factors and Location

A solar water heater works best in places that get a lot of sun and have mild weather. The amount of sunshine your area gets and how warm it is matters. Also consider how often it’s cloudy and how cold it gets.

Reputable Manufacturers and Warranty

It’s smart to buy a solar water heater from a well-known company. Check if it comes with a good warranty to protect your purchase. Fenice Energy is one company known for their quality solar water heaters. They’re experts in making homes more eco-friendly.

Environmental and Financial Benefits

Buying a solar water heating system does more than just give you hot water. It also brings big eco and cost advantages. It uses the sun’s power, which cuts how much you use fossil fuels. This means your home is greener and more eco-friendly.

Reducing Your Carbon Footprint

Solar water heaters cut the amount of greenhouse gases your home puts out. They work by heating water with sunlight. So, you don’t need as much gas or electricity made from coal. This move to sustainable tech fights climate change and makes the future cleaner.

Long-Term Cost Savings and Return on Investment

Solar water heating systems save you money in the long run. Although they cost more at first, the savings add up. You’ll pay less on your energy bills, trimming costs. Plus, there are government supports that make them even more affordable.

Fenice Energy is a top choice for clean energy, like solar and backup systems. They also have EV charging. With a Fenice solar water heater, you get green hot water and save money in the long run.


The choice between Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) and Flat Plate Collectors (FPC) is key for those looking at eco-friendly hot water options. ETCs have a huge leap in heat transfer, about 163% more than FPCs. They also work well in tough weather. However, FPCs are cheaper and last a bit longer.

Fenice Energy has a wide range of clean energy solutions, from solar to backup systems. They have solid experience of over 20 years. When picking a solar water heater, you need to think about your hot water needs. Climate, area, and budget are also key. These help you make a choice that’s good for your home and the planet.

Getting a solar water heater is a smart move for your hot water needs and the environment. It cuts your use of old, polluting water heating ways. This means less carbon footprint and savings that can be as high as INR 50,000 to INR 1,00,000 through the years.


What are the two main types of solar water heating systems based on the solar collectors used?

There are two main types of solar water heating systems. They’re based on the solar collectors they use. These are Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) and Flat Plate Collectors (FPC).

How do Flat Plate Collectors (FPC) work?

Flat Plate Collectors (FPC) use the greenhouse effect to turn sunlight into heat. They have an absorber plate, usually made of copper or aluminum. It’s painted black to soak up the sun’s energy. Tubes or pipes run across this plate. They carry the heated fluid.

How do Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) differ from Flat Plate Collectors?

Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) have a different style than Flat Plate Collectors. They have a line of see-through tubes, each with a heat pipe inside. These tubes are placed in a vacuum to cut down on heat loss. This setup lets ETC systems grab heat from their surroundings, even when it’s cold or cloudy. Then, they send this heat to the water using a header pipe.

Which solar water heater is more efficient, ETC or FPC?

Evacuated Tube Collectors (ETC) are shown to be better at catching and keeping heat than Flat Plate Collectors (FPC). Research suggests they can be up to 163% more effective. This is because of the vacuum insulation in the ETC tubes. It really cuts down on heat loss.

What factors should be considered when selecting a solar water heater?

Picking the right solar water heater means thinking about your family’s hot water needs. You should analyze the number of people in the house, how much water they use, and their hot water needs. This will help you make the best choice.

Reduce your electricity bills by 90%

Get in Touch With Us!

Clean energy for your home & business

[contact-form-7 id="3196c51" title="Blog Contact Form"]